Justice Persecutor From Missouri Fails to Indict a Ham Sandwich; In This case, New York Attorney General. Letitia James

Dec 4, 2025 10:48 PM EST, Thu

Grand jury fails to reindict Letitia James

But sources said there should be “no premature celebrations” because Trump’s Justice Department could try a third time to indict the New York attorney general on alleged mortgage fraud.

Dec. 4, 2025, 6:26 PM EST By Carol Leonnig, Ken Dilanian, Fallon Gallagher, Nora McKee and Lisa Rubin

A federal grand jury decided not to reindict New York Attorney General Letitia James on Thursday on charges of mortgage fraud, according to two law enforcement people briefed on the case.

A Justice Department official declined to comment, saying the agency does not discuss sensitive grand jury matters.

It’s an extremely rare event for a grand jury to reject federal prosecutors’ request that they bring criminal charges — called a “no true bill” — in part because the standard for indicting a subject is very modest. The majority of the members of the grand jury must only find there is probable cause to believe the specific crime occurred.

The two sources, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss a highly sensitive case, said a Missouri prosecutor the Justice Department brought in to indict James plans to try once again to indict the attorney general.

It’s possible that attempt could come as soon as tomorrow, when the Norfolk grand jury is scheduled to meet, one source said.

“There should be no premature celebrations” by James or her supporters, said a person familiar with the Justice Department’s plans.

The case has been plagued by political controversy and factual challenges since the start. Career prosecutors in the Eastern District of Virginia repeatedly objected to bringing mortgage fraud charges against James, as Trump demanded that she be prosecuted.

An acting U.S. attorney resigned his position under pressure after Trump threatened to fire him for resisting the case. Trump then installed an insurance lawyer and his former White House aide, Lindsey Halligan, who obtained an indictment of both James and former FBI Director James Comey, but a judge found she did not have legal authority to do so.

Carol Leonnig is a senior investigative reporter with MS NOW.

Ken Dilanian is the justice and intelligence correspondent for MS NOW.

Fallon Gallagher is a legal affairs reporter for MS NOW.

Nora McKee is the D.C. coordinator for MS NOW.

Lisa Rubin is an MS NOW legal correspondent and a former litigator. Previously, she was the off-air legal analyst for “The Rachel Maddow Show” and “Alex Wagner Tonight.”

Related Posts